Skip to main content

Home  »  Business NewsUS business news   »   AI Giants Clash With California Over Controversial Safety Legislation

AI Giants Clash With California Over Controversial Safety Legislation

AI Giants Clash With California Over Controversial Safety Legislation

California is at the forefront of a heated debate over artificial intelligence regulation. AI startups and tech giants fiercely oppose a bill, SB 1047, progressing through the state legislature. They argue that the proposed regulations are overly vague and could stifle innovation. While some in the industry advocate for federal oversight, they call for more precise guidelines than those in the California bill.

Key Provisions Of SB 1047

SB 1047, which has already passed the state Senate and two Assembly committees, mandates that developers of large AI models—those costing over $100 million to train and meeting a specified computing power threshold—must conduct safety tests to prevent "catastrophic harm." 

This includes damage exceeding $500 million or mass casualties. Additionally, AI systems must have a fail-safe mechanism for human intervention if they behave dangerously. This bill impacts any company operating in California, regardless of its headquarters.

Industry Reactions And Concerns

Opponents, including major tech companies like Meta and OpenAI, argue that the bill’s broad and ambiguous language could hamper innovation. They worry about the lack of detailed guidance on safety tests and the composition of the oversight commission. Microsoft, for example, criticized the bill for potentially leading to misguided investments and ineffective regulations.

employer

Senator Scott Wiener, who authored SB 1047, has expressed openness to amendments.

He said:

“There are people in the tech sector who are opposed to any and all forms of regulation no matter what it is, even for something reasonable and light-touch.”

Need Career Advice? Get employment skills advice at all levels of your career

Despite this, the bill faces significant pushback from the industry, with concerns that it could deter large developers from publicly releasing their models, thus fragmenting the startup ecosystem that thrives on open access.

Support For The Bill

The bill’s proponents, including AI pioneers Geoffrey Hinton and Yoshua Bengio, argue that the measures are necessary to safeguard against future risks. They warn that neglecting such regulations could be a major oversight as more advanced AI systems emerge.

Follow us on YouTubeXLinkedIn, and Facebook


Most Read News