PepsiCo has won a lawsuit in New York that accused it of contributing to plastic pollution in the Buffalo River.
Reuters reports New York State Supreme Court Justice Emilio Colaiacovo dismissed the case on Thursday, criticizing New York Attorney General Letitia James for attempting to link the beverage and snack-food giant to environmental damages.
The Lawsuit’s Claims
Attorney General James filed the lawsuit in November, accusing PepsiCo and its subsidiary, Frito-Lay, of generating 17% of the plastic waste found in and around the Buffalo River.
The lawsuit claimed PepsiCo’s use of single-use plastic packaging amounted to creating a public nuisance and failing to alert consumers about health and environmental risks.
James argued PepsiCo should be held accountable for its plastic waste’s environmental impact, saying the company misled the public regarding its efforts to combat plastic pollution.
Need Career Advice? Get employment skills advice at all levels of your career
Judge’s Ruling and Key Points
Justice Colaiacovo’s decision was clear-cut.
He wrote:
“While I can think of no reasonable person who does not believe in the imperatives of recycling and being better stewards of our environment, this does not give rise to phantom assertions of liability that do nothing to solve the problem that exists.”
He noted it was ultimately individuals, not PepsiCo, who failed to dispose of plastic waste properly. Colaiacovo stated that punishing PepsiCo for public littering would defy legal standards.
He added:
“The judicial system should not be burdened with predatory lawsuits that seek to impose punishment while searching for a crime.”
PepsiCo’s Response to the Dismissal
PepsiCo, headquartered in Purchase, New York, expressed satisfaction with the court’s decision.
A Pepsico spokesperson said:
“We are serious about plastics reduction and effective recycling.”
The company further noted that time and resources are better spent on collaborative, long-term solutions rather than in litigation, which PepsiCo says detracts from real environmental progress.
What’s Next for Plastic Waste and Environmental Efforts?
The court ruling underscores the challenges of assigning direct liability to corporations for widespread issues like plastic waste. Attorney General James has yet to comment on the dismissal.
Environmental activists continue to advocate for stricter regulations on plastic use, urging companies and governments to collaborate on solutions that address pollution at its source.
