Skip to main content

Home  »  Help and Advice for Employers   »   How to handle an employee’s poor performance 

How to handle an employee’s poor performance 

A manager and staff member have a meeting about poor performance

Addressing an employee’s poor performance is a critical challenge that managers may have to face during their careers.

It requires a delicate balance of clear communication, empathy, constructive feedback, and, when necessary, decisive action.

It’s not easy, and can be quite stressful.

Here are strategies and steps to effectively manage and improve an employee’s performance.

Identify the Problem Clearly

The first step in addressing poor performance is to accurately identify the issue.

Is it related to skills, attitude, or factors outside of work?

Understanding the root cause is essential for developing an effective solution. Use specific examples to pinpoint where the performance is lacking.

Evaluate and Document

Before approaching the employee, gather all relevant performance data.

This might include work outputs, project deadlines, attendance records, and any previous feedback.

Documenting this information will help you present a clear and objective case to the employee, and means you can answer any questions they may have.

Prepare for the Conversation

This conversation can be challenging for both the manager and the employee.

Prepare yourself by outlining your talking points, anticipating potential responses, and deciding on the outcomes you wish to achieve.

It’s important to approach the meeting with a constructive and supportive mindset.

You should be prepared for the scenario your team member might not take your comments well.

Communicate Clearly and Constructively

During the meeting, be direct yet empathetic in your communication.

Clearly explain how the employee’s performance is not meeting expectations, using the specific examples and data you’ve gathered.

Avoid generalizations and focus on the facts.

Listen to the Employee

Give the employee a chance to share their side of the story.

There may be underlying issues or misunderstandings that you’re not aware of.

Listening actively shows respect and can provide valuable insights into the situation.

Develop a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP)

Collaborate with the employee to create a Performance Improvement Plan.

The plan should include:

  • Specific, measurable goals: Clearly define what success looks like.
  • Timeline: Set a realistic timeline for achieving these goals.
  • Support and resources: Identify any training, mentoring, or resources the employee needs.
  • Regular check-ins: Schedule frequent meetings to discuss progress and adjust the plan as necessary.

Provide Ongoing Support and Feedback

Supporting the employee through the improvement process is crucial. Offer regular feedback, both positive and constructive.

Recognize improvements to reinforce positive behavior and provide guidance on areas that still need work.

Follow on

The scenario you had to face is that the employee still fails to improve to an adequate standard.

If, despite your best efforts, the employee’s performance does not improve within the agreed timeline, you may need to consider further actions, such as reassignment, demotion, or even termination.

Ensure that any actions taken are in line with your organization’s policies and employment law.

Reflect on the Process

Regardless of the outcome, reflect on the process and what you’ve learned. Consider what went well and what could be improved in the future.

This reflection can help you handle similar situations more effectively.

Create a Culture of Continuous Improvement

Use this experience to foster a culture of continuous improvement within your team. Encourage open communication, provide regular feedback, and support professional development.

This can help prevent performance issues in the future and promote a more engaged and productive team.

Final Thoughts

Dealing with an employee’s poor performance is a difficult and complex task that requires a thoughtful and systematic approach.

By identifying the problem, communicating effectively, providing support, and taking decisive action when necessary, you can help your employee improve and contribute positively to your team.

Remember, the goal is not just to address the immediate issue but to foster an environment of growth, learning, and mutual respect.

Related Articles