The $50 million career crash
The $50 million career crash of James Franklin at Penn State represents one of the most dramatic career collapses in recent memory. In just four games, Franklin went from being one play away from a national championship to being terminated with a $50 million buyout – essentially being paid not to do his job.
This isn’t just a story about college football. It’s a cautionary tale about how quickly careers can unravel, even at the absolute peak of professional success. Franklin’s fall from grace offers crucial lessons for anyone navigating their own career, especially those in leadership positions.
James Franklin’s rise and fall
James Franklin’s career at Penn State was marked by both remarkable success and consistent failure at the most critical moments. Over 11 seasons, he:
- Averaged 10-11 wins per season – Consistently successful regular seasons
- Won a Big 10 championship in 2016 – His peak achievement
- Made the College Football Playoffs – Reached the pinnacle of college football
- Was one play away from a national title game – The ultimate near-miss
- Had everything he asked for – Expanded budgets, expensive staff, recruiting resources
Yet despite all this success, Franklin earned the unfortunate nickname “Big Game James” for his consistent failures in crucial moments, going 2-24 against top-10 ranked teams.
The four-game collapse
Franklin’s career unraveled in just four games this season, starting with a marquee matchup against Oregon:
Game 1: The breaking point
In the first major test of the season – #2 Penn State vs. #6 Oregon – Franklin’s team lost in overtime, adding another heartbreaking defeat to his resume. This loss seemed to fracture something fundamental in Franklin’s psyche.
Games 2-4: The spiral
What followed was a complete tailspin:
- Losses to teams they should have beaten by 20+ points
- Stoic, emotionless press conferences
- Body language that screamed “I’ve given up”
- Players reporting that Franklin had “quit on the team”
As one observer noted: “It was as if we had watched somebody quit on the job and quit on this team.”
The psychology of career burnout
Franklin’s collapse illustrates a common pattern in high-pressure careers – the psychology of repeated near-misses and the toll they take on motivation and confidence.
The ceiling effect
Franklin reached his professional ceiling in 2016 when he won the Big 10 championship. Despite all subsequent efforts and resources, he could never break through to the next level. This pattern of “almost there but never quite making it” can be psychologically devastating.
The confidence spiral
When you repeatedly try to achieve something and fail, always falling just short, it can create a destructive cycle:
- Initial confidence and motivation
- Repeated near-misses
- Growing self-doubt
- Loss of passion and purpose
- Mental checkout and resignation
As the analysis points out: “If you’re never achieving that success or that breakthrough that you’ve been looking for, and you’re always just one inch away or one dollar short, that takes a toll on somebody.”
Warning signs of career burnout
Franklin’s case reveals several warning signs that apply to any career:
Loss of passion
Franklin no longer looked like someone who wanted to be there. His body language, press conferences, and overall demeanor screamed resignation.
Performance decline
He began losing to teams he should easily beat, indicating a loss of focus and motivation.
Team impact
His burnout affected everyone around him – players, staff, and the entire organization suffered from his lack of leadership.
Public disengagement
His stoic, emotionless responses in public suggested someone who had mentally checked out.
Avoid Career Burnout — Take Control Today
Career burnout can drain your passion, performance, and future opportunities. Don’t wait until it’s too late — explore fresh opportunities that reignite your motivation and put you back on track.
Find a Job That Inspires You →The ripple effect of leadership failure
Franklin’s collapse didn’t just affect him – it had devastating consequences for everyone around him:
Impact on players
College athletes preparing for NFL careers saw their draft prospects damaged by the team’s poor performance under a checked-out coach.
Impact on staff
Franklin’s expensive coaching staff now faces uncertainty as a new coach will likely bring in their own team.
Impact on the organization
Penn State was forced to make a $50 million buyout payment, representing a massive financial hit.
Lessons for your career
Franklin’s story offers several crucial lessons for career management:
1. Always have a contingency plan
Even at the peak of success, careers can unravel quickly. You need backup plans for:
- Sudden leadership changes
- Major project failures
- Company bankruptcies
- Scandals or controversies
- Market disruptions
2. Recognize when it’s time to move on
Sometimes the best career move is to leave before you burn out completely. Franklin stayed too long in a situation that was no longer serving him or the organization.
3. Don’t let repeated failures define you
If you’re consistently falling short of your goals, it may be time to reassess your approach or consider a different path entirely.
4. Consider the impact on others
When you’re in a leadership position, your performance affects everyone around you. It’s not just about you anymore.
What happens when leadership changes
Franklin’s departure illustrates what happens to an organization when senior leadership changes:
Staff uncertainty
When a new leader comes in, they typically want to bring their own team. This creates uncertainty for existing staff members.
Changed expectations
New leadership often has different visions of what “good” looks like, potentially making existing high performers less valuable.
The need for adaptation
Remaining staff must quickly adapt to new leadership styles, expectations, and priorities.
How to protect yourself from career crashes
Based on Franklin’s experience, here are strategies to protect your career:
1. Build transferable skills
Franklin’s coaching skills are highly transferable, which is why he’ll have no trouble finding another job. Focus on developing skills that are valuable across different organizations and industries.
2. Maintain your network
Franklin’s reputation and connections in the coaching world will help him land his next position. Keep your professional network strong and active.
3. Know when to pivot
If you’re consistently hitting a ceiling or losing passion, it may be time to consider a different role, company, or even career path.
4. Plan for leadership changes
When new leadership comes in, update your resume and start putting feelers out. Don’t wait for the other shoe to drop.
The importance of self-preservation
Franklin’s story reinforces a crucial career principle: you must put yourself first in your career decisions.
Organizations look out for themselves
Companies, bosses, and organizations will always prioritize their own interests over yours. You need to do the same.
Being selfish isn’t wrong
Making decisions that benefit your career and well-being isn’t selfish – it’s smart. You can still be dedicated and work hard while prioritizing your own interests.
Have a strategy
Don’t wing it in your career. Have a clear strategy, know what you’re doing, and make decisions with conviction based on your long-term goals.
FAQs
Q: How quickly can a career unravel?
A: Careers can unravel shockingly fast. James Franklin went from being one play away from a national championship to being terminated in just four games. This demonstrates how quickly things can change, even at the peak of professional success.
Q: What are the warning signs of career burnout?
A: Warning signs include loss of passion, declining performance, negative impact on team members, public disengagement, and a general sense of “checking out” mentally from your work.
Q: How can I protect myself from career crashes?
A: Build transferable skills, maintain a strong professional network, know when to pivot, plan for leadership changes, and always have contingency plans for unexpected career disruptions.
Q: What should I do when new leadership comes in?
A: Update your resume, start putting feelers out for new opportunities, and be prepared for changed expectations. New leaders often want to bring in their own teams, creating uncertainty for existing staff.
Q: Is it wrong to be selfish in your career?
A: No, it’s not wrong to prioritize your own career interests. Organizations will always look out for themselves first, so you need to do the same. This doesn’t mean you can’t be dedicated or work hard – it means making decisions that benefit your long-term career goals.
Live example — user point of view
As someone who’s watched this unfold, I found Franklin’s career crash absolutely fascinating and terrifying at the same time. Here’s a guy who was at the absolute peak of his profession, making millions of dollars, and it all fell apart in just four games.
What struck me most was how quickly he went from being a successful leader to someone who had clearly checked out mentally. The body language in those press conferences was heartbreaking – you could see he just didn’t want to be there anymore.
I’ve seen similar patterns in my own career and with colleagues. People who were once passionate and driven gradually lose their spark, often because they keep hitting the same ceiling or facing the same obstacles. It’s like watching someone slowly give up on their dreams.
The part about the ripple effect really resonated with me too. When a leader fails, it doesn’t just affect them – it impacts everyone around them. I’ve been in situations where a bad boss or checked-out manager made the entire team miserable and less productive.
This story also reinforced something I’ve learned the hard way: you have to look out for yourself in your career. Companies will always prioritize their own interests, so you need to do the same. Having contingency plans isn’t being disloyal – it’s being smart.
Overall, Franklin’s story is a powerful reminder that even the most successful people can crash and burn, and that we all need to be prepared for unexpected career changes, even when things seem to be going perfectly.
