Starbucks’ new CEO, Brian Niccol, faces mounting challenges as he steps into his role at the coffee giant.
Niccol is tasked with addressing both investor concerns and the demands of Starbucks workers and loyal customers. This is against a backdrop of declining sales and ongoing issues raised by employees.
One of the most pressing issues highlighted by baristas is chronic understaffing. Employees have raised concerns about working conditions, inadequate pay, and insufficient benefits.
Liv Ryan, a barista and union organizer in Long Island, New York, stressed the need to put “an end to short staffing.” She also raised concerns about the lack of adequate support in dealing with difficult customers.
She said while dealing with rude customers is expected, there’s no clear guidance on managing hostile situations.
Other baristas in the Starbucks Workers United union have voiced their desire to see Starbucks commit to the contract bargaining process.
Parker Davis, a union organizer from San Antonio, said:
“All I’m looking for is a collective bargaining agreement by the end of the year.”
Need Career Advice? Get employment skills advice at all levels of your career
Niccol’s Promise: Supporting Baristas and Addressing Bottlenecks
In response to these concerns, Niccol acknowledged the need for changes in his recent video statement.
Niccol highlighted the importance of supporting baristas to deliver “exceptional service” to customers.
This follows a disappointing six percent decline in US same-store sales for the fourth quarter and the company’s decision to pull its earnings guidance for the next fiscal year.
He identified key issues like store staffing, operational bottlenecks, and the need to simplify barista workflows. Niccol assured stakeholders that more details about the company’s changes would be shared during Starbucks’ October 30 earnings call.
Analysts expect Niccol’s strategy to include increasing labor hours and reducing limited-time promotions to ease workloads on baristas, according to Sharon Zackfia, an analyst at William Blair.
Customer Grievances: Complex Menus and Overroasted Coffee
It’s not just employees pushing for change. Starbucks’ hardcore customers are also calling for improvements.
One such customer, Winter, has made it his mission to visit every corporate-owned Starbucks location globally, totaling over 19,000 stores.
Despite his passion for the Starbucks experience, Winter criticized the chain for overcomplicating its menu and serving coffee that is, in his view, overroasted.
Reflecting on his past experiences in 1997, Winter fondly remembered simpler times when Starbucks’ offerings were less complex, and the coffee was more enjoyable.
A Company at a Crossroads
Niccol’s new role at Starbucks comes at a pivotal moment for the company, which has been grappling with worker dissatisfaction, operational challenges, and changes in consumer preferences.
Baristas and customers alike are demanding changes, and the upcoming earnings call is likely to offer more insight into Niccol’s plans.
All eyes will be on how Niccol navigates the dual challenge of supporting Starbucks’ workforce and enhancing the customer experience in an evolving market.
